Commentary

Original goals from my LIPD

What elements of the Learning Intentions and Pathway Design were met?

To evaluate what goals of my Learning Intentions and Pathway Design (LIPD) were met, postponed or discarded I created the table „Tracking goals from my LIPD“. I also added my new main goals in the table.

The Mindmap „LIPD goals“ shows my original goals that I created for my Learning Intentions and Pathway Design. To read my LIPD, just click here.

Tracking Goals

Tracking goals from LIPD

Reflection on Project Development

In the beginning, I wanted to write my OP about herb field and business. During the time I realized that we intuitively experimented with growing and processing herbs and designing a business plan. I did not feel that I wanted to write an OP in this stage of project development. Instead, the new idea of creating a pattern design for our property developed. That made for us the most sense, as wee really need to define different areas on the property. Otherwise, we would design everything intuitively during the years. So a pattern design of the property is the basis for any further development.

What went well?
It felt that one step after the other happened without being after the next steps too much. The decision of starting with the Permaculture Diploma combined with my Bachelor was very easy. After I got the Portfolio Review (that was necessary to evaluate how permacultural I worked in the past) of my Permaculture Mentor, I was clear what next steps to take and where to work on. This was the time when I consciously started with the project.

What was challenging?
Although I tried to document the project development in an offline desktop Wiki (ZIM), ongoing documentation of the project was very challenging.
Also, it was sometimes challenging to decide on the adjustable level of detail I want to observe or document for the different phases of the Design Process „SADIED“ (Survey, Analysis, Design, Implement, Evaluate, Develop).

OP Design

It was the first time I consciously designed my OP at the beginning of all work. I integrated all the Feedback to secure to miss as less as possible during work. It was very effective and time-saving! Although I spend a lot of time in planning I was a lot faster in producing the OP than ever before. In mind I had the permaculture saying: 80 percent for planning and 20 percent well-thought implementation. View my OP Design in the PDF "OP-Design"

OP Process Reflection

What went well?
I strategically designed my OP and spent a lot of time designing each Portfolio Page and the paragraphs included. That was very helpful, so I was able to work even for little time frames.
I never lost the thread for writing the OP and I could work in a flow.
Consciously designed OP working days in my grandmother's house helped me to focus on the work. Through the limited amount of time, I was forced to work productively during this time.

What was challenging?
We had a lot of „worksites“ in our house, property and private life that we needed to organize while I was writing this OP. I tried to integrate all the Feedback from my last OP and the Portfolio Review, but still, I am not sure what is missing in this OP.

Reflection on Core Report Process SADIED

What went well?
SADIED (Survey, Analysis, Design, Implemented so far, Evaluate the implementation and reached outcomes, Develop a timeline for the future) is an adapted Design Process of SADIE (Survey, Analysis, Design Implement, Evaluate). This adapted Process helped me to put different steps into different phases. With this process, I was able to give a holistic view of our project and design.
Applying a typical land-based design and going through pre-defined phases helped me to structure my work in the right order. It was also nice to experience that there are a lot online and offline (books) resources available that work with this process and provide detailed instructions and examples.

What was challenging?
It took a while to play around with different adaptations of the process SADIE and also to define what I will implement in every phase.

Pathway Reflection and Project Integration – Comment on Future Pathway

Pathway Reflection
With the new situation that we are the owner of a property since the end of 2018, many things became more specific for my pathway.

The consideration of combining my Bachelor Degree with the Permaculture Diploma was suddenly more relevant than ever before and I decided to actively reach out to GaiaU and find out more about the requirements.

It took a few months to clarify all requirements and find a Permaculture Mentor, which is Nesrin Caglac.

The focus on permaculture will enable me to design our property according to these criteria, get familiar with different permaculture design tools and build up permaculture skills on a professional level. It also gives a focus for my Bachelor Degree. That helps me to work more effectively on a certain project because I know the project needs to fulfill permaculture criteria. In fact I I felt a few months in the “waiting position” without working effectively on my project because I was not clear about the new requirements. But as soon as I was clear about them, I concentrated started to design my future pathway and OP 4.

Project Integration
The project “designing a pattern design for our property” is the main element for our life and future. Without this design as a basis, we are not able to make any conscious intervention on the land. In my eyes, pattern design is a good start for the beginning of a permaculture design series. In future land designs, I can always refer to the pattern design.

This was a project that was from high relevance also in our private life and it helps us to come closer to our vision and goals.

Future Pathway:
To take a look in the future I created a preliminary timeline for my pathway and Ops. My goal is to complete the Capstone Phase within just a year. I am not sure how long I will go into baby-pause, that depends on the circumstances I am not able to plan now.

Preliminary timeline for pathway and OPs

Timeline Pathway and OP

Pathway and Program Requirements

Main Advising
Main Advising Session left: 4,5 h

Skill-flex advising
Virginia: growing herbs (recording on the left)

Permaculture Mentoring
Nesrin Caglak, my permaculture mentor, visits us in person in October.

The budget for the Permaculture Mentoring Session of OP4 is used there. Additionally, I am able to use the budget from my Learning Support Budget and Skill-flex-advising. Maybe also from Main Advising. I clarify that with my Main Advisor, Laura Kaestele

Presentations
Mid-of year presentation: Done
End-of-year presentation: planned for December 2019

Gaia Radio Calls: attended none

My Main Advisor, Laura Kaestele, created a Table that shows my Program Requirements and available services for both, the Bachelor Degree and the Permaculture Diploma.
The table can be downloaded below.

Field analysis

Field analysis

Practical Benefits to the Field

To be conscious about the field we are currently working in I updated my Field analysis from OP3.
You can see the graphic on the right. I changed some fields and added new goals.
The fields we are working in are defined in the second circle.

In the following I describe our interventions/actions and their impact for each field:

Gardening: focus on herbs

Interventions/actions I am working towards

  •  a 1000 sqm big herb field (including different living spaces/microclimates) with annual and perennial herbs
  • harvesting and processing herbs to high-quality products

Impact

  • ecological valuable: fodder for many insects is provided, biotopes develop where perennial herbs are grown
  • economic impact: build up a business and reach financial independence
  • personal impact: become an expert in the field
  • marketing: offer people organic high-quality products that they can not buy in the supermarket

Permaculture

Interventions/actions I am working towards

  • absolve the Permaculture Diploma within GaiaU
  • design our land with the help of permaculture so that it is an integral system
  • design gardens/properties for clients

Impact

  • Personal: gain professional skills in land design
  • Property: example of a professional holistic permaculture farm
  • Clients: designing the world towards a permacultural lifestyle

Workshops

Interventions and Actions I am working towards

  • leading regular workshops in the local kindergarten and school
  • leading workshops for adults about specific topics (tinctures, insect-friendly design of our environment, etc, )

Impact

  • pass on knowledge and make people aware of topics related to real sustainability

Supporting Insects

Intervention/ Action I am working towards

  • an area of our property is dedicated to insects
  • different biotopes exist on the property
  • implementing a biotope in a public space of our local village (build up a network for biotopes)

Impact

  • contribution to the survival of (rare) species
  • inviting people who are interested in designing biotopes for insects
  • biotopes in many villages will effectively contribute to the survival of rare species

Natural garden

Intervention/action I am working towards

  • our property is designed with many elements of the natural garden movement

Impact

  • biotopes for many animals and plants
  • people can gain inspirations for their own garden

 

Managing Time and Promises

Project Management

Project roles:
Two persons share the responsibilities for the land
Me: the initiator of the project creating a „Pattern Design“;
Fabian: interview partner and exchange of ideas and possibilities

Management tools:
ZIM: Offline Wiki
To document my work I mainly used the offline Wiki Zim; an individual structure is possible, to-does can be added and cross marked and every topic can have an individual page.

Nevertheless, in the end, it was a bit confusing, because there was too much information and I lost the discipline to categorize topics.

Managing time:

During pregnancy, I recognized that I want to finish my Action Learning Cycle before I give birth to our second child. So I estimated my time and wanted to submit OP4 in September. But I needed to wait for the Portfolio Review to integrate the Feedback in my next OP time was too meager. So I renegotiated to submit OP4 in October and OP5 in December 2019.

Best practices in Tracking:

  • Word Documents helped to structure topics, these documents were: OP Design, Commentary, Core Report.
    With the help of the structure of the Core Report, I was able to work and implement focused my „To Does“. I chronologically went through my exercises and was sure at the same time that I use my time efficiently and that I can use the material produced directly in the Core Report. That was actually the most effective management tool I experienced so far
  • Compiled a file for all my notes, drawings and thoughts: The file is sorted like the Core Report

Challenges:

  • estimate how long a task needs to be fulfilled and how much detail is needed
  • a clear documentation structure is still missing

Life Update

The main personal update I delighted want to share is that I am pregnant with our second child and I will give birth in January 2020. Being a mother of two children is a great gift and I am very thankful. Nevertheless, I felt that the next year will require a lot of energy (physical, emotional and psychical) and sometimes I am asking myself how I am able to manage two children and our project.

We are still not allowed to live on the land. In autumn 2019 we want to visit the department of construction and ask for the approval of our greenhouse. We also want to carefully ask during the visit, if it might be possible to sleep in the herb hut because we need to work when the children are sleeping in the evening.

Let's see how it develops.

Journals

Monthly check-ins with my peer guild, helped me to document and collect our ongoing process.

At the same time, they were valuable for a group exchange. Every one of the group knows what the peers are working on, where the challenges and highlights are and if they need help.

Click here to open the check-ins in Dropbox.

Comments

Carolina Winter
01 October 2019, 11:11

Carolina Winter
09 October 2019, 2:49

2 comments